What Every Church Website Needs (But Often Misses)
What Every Church Website needs (But Often Misses)
There seems to be a wave of people looking for a church these days. People are searching for hope, seeking answers, looking for community, and just trying to find a place to turn to.
And where do most people look first? Google.
Someone types "church near me" or "churches in [your town]" into a search bar and starts going down the list.
Even if a friend invites them, they're still going to your website to check you out first.
Within seconds of landing on your site, they've decided whether to keep looking or move to the next website on the list. They're not reading your mission statement yet. They're not learning about your ministries. They want to know three things fast:
When you meet
Where you meet
And what happens if I show up
Let's face it - going anywhere for the first time is scary. Going to church for the first time is especially scary.
And even more so if you're going by yourself.
It's daunting showing up at an unknown place. “Which door do I go in?” “Will anyone speak to me?” “What if I unknowingly sit in someone's 'regular' seat?”
Your website should remove all fears and doubts someone has. The goal is to say "There’s a spot for you. Here's everything you need to know. And we can't wait to see you."
And you do that by not just saying those words, but by every other facet of your website: how easy the information is to find, the images you choose, the tone of your text, all of it working together to get someone excited to walk through your doors.
Here's how to do that:
PUT SERVICE TIMES AND LOCATION WHERE PEOPLE CAN ACTUALLY SEE THEM
Here's the first test your website has to pass: Can someone find your service times and address without clicking around? Bonus points if they can find it without even scrolling.
You'd be surprised how many church websites fail at this. I recently went to another church's Sunday morning service for a special event. I went to their website to find the service times, and it took me 4 clicks before I finally found it. Talk about frustrating!
The fix is simple. Put your service time and address somewhere that is impossible to miss, right in the header, the hero section, or an announcement bar that shows on every page. Don't make it compete for attention with everything else on your homepage.
This is the one piece of information every single visitor needs, so treat it that way.
Give First-Time Visitors One Clear Next Step
More than likely your website has several links in the top navigation for people to click - About, Staff, Events, Sermons, Ministries, etc. This isn't a bad thing. But if someone is a visiting your site for the first time, they need to be guided on what to click next instead of being overwhelmed by the choices.
What's actually helpful is an obvious button - "Start Here", "Plan Your Visit", "I'm New" - that stands out from everything else. Using a different color for that button will also help it to stand out.
The “Start Here” page (or whatever you choose to call it) should answer all of the questions they have:
What do I wear?
Where do I park?
What happens with my kids?
How long does the service run?
These aren't small questions to someone walking into an unfamiliar building alone. Answering them clearly is one of the best things you can do to ease their fears.
Use Photos That Help People Picture Themselves There
Walking into a place you've never been is intimidating. Walking in alone, to a church, for the first time, is a specific kind of nerve-wracking. Good photos do a lot of the work of calming that fear.
This means high-resolution, real photos. Real people from your actual congregation, not stock photos of strangers who've never set foot in your building. People smiling, people worshiping, people talking to each other after a service. Use shots from inside your actual space, not just the outside of the building.
Someone visiting your site is trying to answer a question, “What will it feel like to be there”?
Photos answer that faster than any amount of copy can.
Make the Path to Getting Connected Obvious
Someone shows up. They liked it. Now what?
This is where a lot of church websites dump a wall of ministry names on people that mean nothing to an outsider. "Join a Life Group." "Fill out a Connect Card." If you didn't grow up in this world, none of that means anything yet.
Spell it out in plain language. What does getting connected actually look like, step by step, for someone who just started showing up? Keep the jargon out of it, at least on the first page they'd land on. Save the insider language for people who already know it.
Keep Sermons Easy to Find and Browse
If you're building your website on Squarespace, the blog feature can do more here than people realize. Set it up so that each sermon becomes its own post, with categories for series and tags for speaker or scripture reference.
Use the built in Summary Block or Universal Filter on your sermons page so visitors can browse by topic, by series, or by book of the Bible.
You might not expect a "blog" to be the right fit for sermons, but it does the job nicely. The key is setting up your categories and tags correctly from the start, so the archive stays useful as it grows instead of turning into an unsorted pile of posts.
Don't Let Your Events Page Go Stale
An events page with outdated listings does more harm than no events page at all. It tells a visitor that nobody's paying attention to this site. If your latest event was six months ago, it makes your website look cold and stagnant.
Keep it current, even if that means simplifying it to just the next few weeks instead of trying to maintain a year's worth of events.
Use Real Testimonials, Placed Where They Matter
Testimonials work differently for a church than they do for a business. What works is something short and personal: a sentence or two from a real member about how their life was changed or what they found here that they weren't finding elsewhere.
Placement matters more than volume. A couple of honest, specific quotes near your About section or your Start Here page will do more than a long list buried at the bottom of the homepage.
And keep it feeling like a real voice, not marketing copy. Church visitors can tell the difference, and it costs you trust if it reads like a sales pitch.
The Website Isn't the Point. Getting Someone Through the Door Is.
None of this is about building an impressive website. It's about removing the reasons someone decides not to come.
Every feature here, the service times up top, the one clear next step, the real photos, the easy-to-browse sermons, exist to answer the same question a nervous first-time visitor is asking: “Is this a place I could actually walk into?”
If your website answers that clearly, you've already done the hardest part.
If your church's website is missing any of these items, I can help. I've spent years building sites for ministries, church organizations, and faith-based brands, and I'd love to help you build something that actually gets people through the door. [Reach out / Let's talk / Get in touch] and let's take a look at what your site needs.
*This post may contain affiliate links, so I may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on this site at no additional cost to you.
